"Forget about it"

FOUR POETS LAUREATE
by JoAnne Henderson
09/23/02

On September 21st, I had the great pleasure of attending one day of the four-day Geraldine R. Dodge Poetry Festival 2002 in Stanhope NJ. Hearing poems read by Edward Hirsch, Li-Young Lee and Grace Paley was worth the ticket price. As a bonus, I listened to four US Poets Laureate reflect on the office.

When Rita Dove got the phone call offering her the position, she thought, "It will ruin my life but I'd be crazy not to accept it." In fact, being Poet Laureate did ruin her writing life for several years. Ms. Dove had no idea what the office would be like, so she decided to do what needed to be done and "they'd stop me when the money ran out." Her goal was to bring poetry wherever she could, and she brought it to the US Naval Academy, to Sesame Street, to church basements. Ms. Dove read poetry in schools and in one minute public service announcements on cable TV. She went to lunch with members of Congress to find out what was happening in their home states. Often they wouldn't know, but then they'd go home and do something.

When Robert Hass' phone rang, he thought, "I'm being asked to be class monitor!" He saw himself having to attend "lots of receptions where there would be little cubes of cheddar cheese with toothpicks."

Hass pointed out that the position was once called Consultant in Poetry to the Librarian of Congress. Senator Spark Matsunaga of Hawaii lobbied over twenty years for the term "Poet Laureate." In 1985, Congress finally changed the office's title to "Poet Laureate Consultant in Poetry." According to Hass, the first person called US Poet Laureate was Robert Penn Warren, who took the small stipend and never showed up in Washington, DC. Instead, he stayed home and wrote All the Kings Men.

The US Poet Laureate is an apparently autocratic appointment by the Librarian of Congress. It was an office that was scarcely noticed, Hass said, until a Russian Librarian of Congress named a Russian poet, Joseph Brodsky, in 1991.

That got the attention of the press. Now five minutes after accepting the position, a new Poet Laureate is handling calls from The New York Times and "The Today Show." Hass said it was front page news in San Francisco that a local poet had been named Poet Laureate. He felt like he was inside a bubble where "all the attention in the world was on me." He even got letters addressed to Robert Frost.

Robert Pinsky stressed the ambivalence that many Poets Laureate feel about the position. In the first place, he sees the old title "Consultant in Poetry" to the Librarian of Congress as a more noble title, one that reflects service to the people. "'Laureate' is more royal sounding and Americans are suckers for that," he says. "'Laureate' has cachet, but it also sounds like you're serving an elite group." To Pinsky, Poet Laureate has become a job where you're "sort of trying to constantly create culture with a small stipend, no staff, and a tiny travel budget." He'd rather see it be a literary honor, where Poets Laureate didn't have to be "hucksters for poetry" unless they chose to be.

When the current US Poet Laureate, Billy Collins, received his phone call, he was told, "You're the Poet Laureate." This led him to believe that the Librarian of Congress had called five other people who had said no, and he wasn't being given the option of declining. (T. S. Eliot, in fact, turned the position down.)

Collins said that a friend commented that the odds of his "being named Poet Laureate were like the chances of a Chia pet winning the Preakness!" Collins suggested that the whole thing was a "government plot to take one poet out of commission, by making him so busy he can't write." He spoke of receiving bizarre mail, particularly from "people with delusions of grandeur -- either about their own poetry or their children's."

American culture has become more open to poetry in recent years. Rita Dove was on Sesame Street and Lifetime, and Robert Hass did a syndicated newspaper column for years. Robert Pinsky read poems on "The News Hour," and got enough responses to his Favorite Poem Project to fill two books. Billy Collins observes that radio, especially NPR, is a perfect medium for poetry. "Radio can ambush you with a poem. You're riding in a car or making an omelet, and a poem pops up. It puts poetry in the stream of everyday life."

One audience member asked if Poets Laureate felt pressured by the press to respond to major events. Pinsky, who was the past Poet Laureate on September 11th, 2001, responded that he made up a kit of five or six poems already in existence to give to reporters, and fairly soon new poetry about 9/11 was being written. Pinsky did not feel pressured by the press; rather, he liked answering the question, "What does poetry say about this?"

A frivolous moment was spent discussing what to call a group of Poets Laureate, such as the one currently gathered. Hass suggested a "strophe of Laureates." "A gaggle of Laureates," Collins offered. Pinsky's "laundromat of Laureates" drew chuckles from the crowd.

More laughter followed when Billy Collins, who had said earlier that the next Poet Laureate should be a woman, reversed gears. In England, Poet Laureate used to be a lifetime post. "We should make ours a lifetime appointment," he said. "Starting now."


More by JoAnne HendersonRtn to Columnists
Senior CheckingPoetry by JoAnneEyebrows
May \'03The Writing ClassThe Wolf and the Seven Little Kids
Four Poets LaureateEmpty Nest and Other Syndromes